Greek schools希臘的學校
Athens and Alexandria light up. Most of what was written here was in Greek.
雅典和亞歷山卓亮起來。這裡寫的東西大多是希臘文。
World History · Unit 3 · Lesson 11 · 世界歷史 單元三 第十一課
Follow seven books on a 3D globe as they are copied and translated from Greek, Sanskrit, and Arabic into Syriac, Arabic, Latin, and Chinese, from Alexandria and Baghdad to Toledo, Pisa, and Chang'an. Find out where words like algebra and zero came from.
在 3D 地球儀上跟著七本書走,看它們從希臘文、梵文和阿拉伯文,被抄寫、翻譯成敘利亞文、阿拉伯文、拉丁文和中文,從亞歷山卓、巴格達一路到托雷多、比薩和長安。找一找 algebra(代數)、zero(零)這些字從哪裡來。
Knowledge did not stay in one place. Greek, Persian, and Indian books were translated into Syriac and Arabic in Baghdad, studied and improved there, and later translated into Latin in Spain and Italy; Buddhist books went from Sanskrit into Chinese. The people who kept knowledge alive spoke many languages and followed different religions.
知識沒有一直待在同一個地方。希臘、波斯和印度的書在巴格達被譯成敘利亞文和阿拉伯文,在那裡被研究、被改進,後來又在西班牙和義大利被譯成拉丁文;佛經則從梵文譯成中文。保存知識的人說很多種語言,也信不同的宗教。
3D Model · 3D 模型
Drag the slider from 400 BCE to 1500 CE, or press Play, and watch places of learning light up. Then choose a book under “Follow a book.” A glowing dot carries it from one place to the next, and the card shows which language it was translated into at each stop. Click a place to read what happened there and how we know.
把滑桿從西元前 400 年拉到西元 1500 年,或按「播放」,看學術的地方一個一個亮起來。接著在「跟著一本書走」選一本書:發光的小點把它從一個地方帶到下一個地方,卡片會寫出每一站它被譯成什麼語言。點一個地方,讀那裡發生了什麼、我們怎麼知道。
Drag to turn · 拖曳轉動 Scroll or pinch to zoom · 滾輪/雙指縮放 Click a dot · 點圓點
This 3D globe needs WebGL, which this browser does not support. The time slider, the place cards, and “Follow a book” still work, and so do the games below.
這個瀏覽器不支援 WebGL,無法顯示 3D 地球儀;時間滑桿、地方小卡和「跟著一本書走」照樣能用,下面的小遊戲也都能用。
This is a teaching sketch. The lines connect places of learning in the rough order they flourished; they are not exact roads. The map shows land only, with no modern borders.
這是教學用的示意。線把學術的地方依它們興盛的大約先後連起來,不是確切的道路。地圖只畫陸地,不畫今天的國界。
Globe: land outlines from Natural Earth (public domain). Places and dates follow the sources listed at the bottom of the page. 地球儀:陸地外形取自 Natural Earth(公有領域)。地方和年代依本頁最下面列出的資料。
Reading · 英文閱讀
Before printing spread, every book had to be copied by hand. A book survived only if people kept making new copies, and only if someone could read its language. When nobody copied a book for a few hundred years, it could be lost forever. So the question “who kept knowledge alive?” has many answers, in many languages.
Some of the most famous books were written in Greek. Plato taught at the Academy in Athens, and Euclid taught geometry in Alexandria about 300 BCE. Around 150 CE Ptolemy wrote his great book of astronomy there, and the physician Galen, born in Pergamum, wrote many books on medicine. In Constantinople, Byzantine scribes went on copying Greek books for centuries.
In India, scholars wrote in Sanskrit. In 628 the astronomer Brahmagupta treated zero as a number with its own rules. The numerals we use today, from 0 to 9, began in India in the 6th or 7th century. At the monastery of Nalanda, the Chinese pilgrim Xuanzang learned Sanskrit; back in Chang'an from 645, he translated the scriptures he had brought into Chinese. In China, too, a Buddhist text printed in 868 is the oldest printed book that carries a date.
In Baghdad, the Abbasid caliphs kept a royal library called the House of Wisdom, and their court supported many scholars. Translators turned Persian, Indian, Syriac, and Greek works into Arabic, some of them close to the court. The mathematician al-Khwārizmī wrote about Indian numerals and about algebra. A generation later, Hunayn ibn Ishaq, a Christian physician, gathered Greek manuscripts and translated Galen into Syriac and Arabic.
Scholars did not only copy. Avicenna's Canon of Medicine, Ibn al-Haytham's book on optics, and al-Khwārizmī's algebra added new ideas. In Seville and Córdoba, Averroes wrote commentaries on Aristotle, which also survive in Hebrew translation. Then, in the 12th century, translators in Toledo, a city taken by the Christian king Alfonso VI in 1085, turned many of these Arabic books into Latin. Gerard of Cremona went there to learn Arabic just to read Ptolemy.
In Latin Europe, monks had been copying books in monastery writing rooms all along, and the new universities after 1100 were stimulated by Arabic learning. In West Africa, Timbuktu became a center of Islamic culture and learning. Knowledge survived because people in many places, speaking Greek, Syriac, Arabic, Persian, Sanskrit, Chinese, Hebrew, and Latin, kept copying, translating, and asking new questions.
Questions · 閱讀理解
Why could a book be lost forever before printing?
Name two languages that Galen's books passed through on their way to Latin Europe.
Give one example of a scholar who did more than copy older books.
Words & Phrases · 生字及片語
Quick Check · 小測驗
1. Why did books have to be copied again and again?
2. Where did the numerals 0 to 9 begin?
3. Who was Hunayn ibn Ishaq?
4. Why did Gerard of Cremona go to Toledo?
5. Which English word comes from the title of al-Khwārizmī's book?
Try It in the Model · 在模型裡試試
Then follow Avicenna's Canon and the Buddhist scriptures. How are their journeys different from the others?
接著跟著阿維森納的《醫典》和佛經走。它們的旅程和其他幾本有什麼不一樣?
Athens and Alexandria light up. Most of what was written here was in Greek.
雅典和亞歷山卓亮起來。這裡寫的東西大多是希臘文。
Follow the Almagest from Greek into Arabic and then into Latin. Count the languages.
跟著《天文學大成》,從希臘文到阿拉伯文,再到拉丁文。數一數有幾種語言。
The numerals start in India, not in Greece. Watch where they go next.
數字從印度出發,不是從希臘。看它們接下來到哪裡。
By now places of learning stretch from Toledo and Timbuktu to Dunhuang and Chang'an. Which languages were spoken in each?
這時學術的地方已經從托雷多、廷巴克圖延伸到敦煌和長安。每一個地方說的是哪一種語言?
Game · 小遊戲
Many English words for science and learning traveled the same road as the books. For each Chinese word, pick the older word it came from and its English form. There is no timer.
很多英文的科學和學術用字,和書走的是同一條路。每一個中文詞,選出它來源的那個比較古老的字,以及它的英文。不計時。
Right on the first try · 第一次就配對正確 0 / 0
Which older word did it come from, and what is it in English?它來自哪一個比較古老的字?英文是哪一個?
Game · 小遊戲
Put these moments in the story of knowledge in order, from earliest to most recent. Use the arrows or drag them. Then check your order.
把這些知識故事裡的時刻,從最早排到最晚。用箭頭或拖曳來移動,然後檢查。
Earliest · 最早
Most recent · 最晚
Parallel Timeline · 平行時間軸
Learning flourished in different places at different times. Notice how Baghdad's great age comes between Alexandria's and Toledo's.
學術在不同的時間,在不同的地方興盛。注意巴格達最興盛的時候,剛好在亞歷山卓和托雷多之間。
Click a bar or a diamond to read its dates.點一條長條或一個菱形,讀出它的年代。
How Do We Know? · 我們怎麼知道?
Historians trace a book's journey by looking at the copies that survive and the lists people made of books.
歷史學家看留下來的抄本,以及人們編的書目,來追查一本書的旅程。
Many manuscripts end with a note, called a colophon, saying who made the copy and when. The Diamond Sutra from Dunhuang has one: it was made for free distribution by Wang Jie on behalf of his parents, on a day equal to May 11, 868.
很多抄本在最後有一段題記,寫著誰抄的、什麼時候抄的。敦煌的《金剛經》就有一段:一位叫 Wang Jie 的人,為了父母而印、讓大家免費取得,日期相當於 868 年 5 月 11 日。
Its limits · 它的限制Many copies have no note at all, and many early printed editions of translations leave out the translator's name, so historians have to argue about who translated what.很多抄本根本沒有題記;許多早期印刷的譯本也沒寫譯者是誰,所以歷史學家還要爭論誰譯了什麼。
British Library, International Dunhuang Programme; Britannica, “Gerard of Cremona” ↗In 988 a bookseller, Ibn al-Nadim, compiled the Fihrist, an index of the Arabic books of his time, from language study to alchemy.
988 年,書商伊本・納迪姆編了《書目》(Fihrist),列出他那個時代的阿拉伯文書,從語言學到煉金術都有。
Its limits · 它的限制Most of the books on the list have since been lost. A list tells us a book existed, not what was in it.書目上的書,後來大多已經失傳。書目告訴我們有過這本書,但不告訴我們書裡寫了什麼。
Britannica, “Ibn al-Nadim” ↗Parchment was expensive, so old writing was sometimes scraped off and the page reused. A copy of works by Archimedes made in the 900s was turned into a prayer book in 1229 at a monastery near Bethlehem. After it was sold in 1998, scientists used ultraviolet light and X-rays to read the Archimedes text underneath.
羊皮紙很貴,所以舊的字有時會被刮掉,紙再拿來用。一部 900 年代的阿基米德抄本,1229 年在伯利恆附近的修道院被改成祈禱書。1998 年它被賣出以後,科學家用紫外光和 X 光,讀出了底下阿基米德的字。
Its limits · 它的限制Most scraped-off texts are lost for good. We only know about the ones that happened to survive and be studied.大部分被刮掉的字,已經永遠消失了。我們只知道剛好留下來、又被研究過的那些。
Smithsonian Magazine, “Reading Between the Lines” ↗Different Accounts · 不同的說法
Historians agree that translation mattered enormously, but they disagree on some details. Here are four questions, with the views set side by side.
歷史學家都同意翻譯非常重要,但對一些細節看法不同。下面是四個問題,各種說法並列。
A great translation center一座大型的翻譯中心
Britannica's short summary at the top of its article calls it a “royal library and translation center” of the Abbasid caliphs.
Britannica 條目開頭的簡介,把它叫做阿拔斯王朝哈里發的「王室圖書館兼翻譯中心」。
A royal library; translation happened elsewhere王室圖書館;翻譯在別的地方
Britannica's full article says translation, almost all from Persian, was not one of its main jobs, and that the translation of Greek works, including Hunayn's, took place elsewhere. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy agrees that it cannot be viewed as an institutional center for translating Greek works, though the first translators had close ties to the court.
Britannica 的正文說,翻譯(幾乎都是從波斯文)不是它主要的工作;希臘著作的翻譯,包括侯奈因的,是在別的地方進行的。《史丹佛哲學百科》也說,它不能看成翻譯希臘著作的正式機構,不過最早的那些譯者和宮廷關係很密切。
Where things stand · 目前的情況Britannica's full article and the Stanford Encyclopedia agree on the second view. Either way, the caliphs' court and Baghdad's elites supported translators.Britannica 的正文和《史丹佛哲學百科》都支持第二種看法。不管哪一種,哈里發的宮廷和巴格達的上層人士都支持譯者。
To carry on Persian traditions延續波斯的傳統
For the royal library, Britannica points to Persian heritage: possibly modeled on Sasanian practice, it specialized in Persian knowledge and showed the dynasty continuing that heritage.
就王室圖書館來說,Britannica 指向波斯的傳統:它可能仿照薩珊王朝的做法,專精波斯的知識,表現出這個王朝延續那份傳統。
New ideas and new interests新的想法和新的興趣
For the translations of Greek works, the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy points to al-Maʾmūn's new view of Islam and of the caliph's role, and to the growing interest of educated elites in the secular sciences.
就希臘著作的翻譯來說,《史丹佛哲學百科》指出,是馬蒙對伊斯蘭和哈里發角色的新看法,加上受過教育的上層人士對世俗學問越來越有興趣。
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Greek Sources in Arabic and Islamic Philosophy” ↗
Where things stand · 目前的情況The two answers are about different kinds of books, and they can overlap: rulers, physicians, astronomers, and officials all had their own uses for these books.兩個答案談的是不同種類的書,也可以同時成立:統治者、醫生、天文學家和官員,對這些書各有各的用處。
In 48 BCE西元前 48 年
One account in Britannica says the main library was destroyed in a civil war in 48 BCE, and a smaller “daughter library” in 391 CE.
Britannica 的一種說法是,主圖書館在西元前 48 年的內戰中被毀,另一座較小的「分館」在西元 391 年被毀。
In the late 3rd century CE西元三世紀後期
Another passage in the same encyclopedia says the library was destroyed in a civil war under the Roman emperor Aurelian, in the late 3rd century CE.
同一部百科的另一段說,圖書館是在三世紀後期羅馬皇帝奧勒良時的內戰中被毀的。
Where things stand · 目前的情況The sources do not agree, and the library probably declined in more than one stage rather than vanishing in a single fire.資料彼此不一致;圖書館大概是分好幾個階段衰落的,不是一場大火就消失。
Around 1000大約 1000 年
Britannica says the scholar Gerbert, later Pope Sylvester II, introduced an abacus with counters bearing Arabic numerals around 1000 CE, though very few people knew of it.
Britannica 說,學者熱爾貝(後來的教宗西爾維斯特二世)大約在西元 1000 年用了一種算盤,算子上刻著阿拉伯數字;不過知道的人很少。
About the 12th century and after大約十二世紀以後
Britannica's article on the numerals says they reached Europe through Middle Eastern mathematicians, especially al-Khwārizmī and al-Kindī, about the 12th century, and Fibonacci's book of 1202 did much to spread them.
Britannica 談數字的條目說,它們大約在十二世紀,透過中東的數學家(特別是花拉子密和金迪)傳到歐洲;費波那契 1202 年的書,大大幫助了它們的傳播。
Where things stand · 目前的情況Both can be true: a few scholars knew the numerals early, but most people in Europe went on using Roman numerals for a long time.兩種說法可以同時成立:少數學者很早就知道這些數字,但歐洲大多數人還用了很久的羅馬數字。
Notice that even good encyclopedias sometimes give more than one answer.留意:連很好的百科全書,有時也會給出不只一個答案。
History English · 歷史英語
These sentences help you describe how ideas were saved and passed on. Listen, repeat, then make your own sentence with the words in bold.
這八句幫你描述想法怎麼被保存、怎麼傳下去。先聽、再跟著唸,然後用粗體的字自己造一句。
The book was translated from Greek into Arabic.
這本書從希臘文被譯成阿拉伯文。
be translated from A into B: put into another language從 A 譯成 B
Every copy was made by hand.
每一份都是手抄的。
by hand: without a machine用手做的
Monks preserved old books.
修士保存了古老的書。
preserve: keep safe for the future保存
Some of Galen's books were lost in Greek.
蓋倫有些希臘文原書失傳了。
be lost: no longer exist失傳
Al-Khwārizmī built on Indian ideas.
花拉子密以印度的想法為基礎。
build on: use as a starting point以……為基礎
Ibn al-Haytham questioned Ptolemy's models.
伊本・海什木質疑托勒密的模型。
question: ask whether something is right質疑
English borrowed the word algebra from Arabic.
英文從阿拉伯文借了 algebra 這個字。
borrow A from B: take a word into your language從……借用
Scholars passed on what they had learned.
學者把學到的東西傳了下去。
pass on: give to the next person傳下去
Taiwan at That Time · 那時候的台灣
Before 1600 the peoples of Taiwan kept and passed on knowledge through speech, skills, and customs rather than books.
1600 年以前,台灣的人群不是用書,而是用語言、技術和習俗,保存、傳下知識。
Archaeologists in Taiwan give dates as “years ago.” About 2,000 years ago is roughly the beginning of the Common Era.
台灣的考古學家用「距今幾年」說年代。距今大約兩千年,差不多是西元紀年開始的時候。
Shisanhang culture, north北部的十三行文化
The museum says the Shisanhang people had the skill to smelt iron themselves. A skill like this lives only if it is taught to the next generation.
史前館說,十三行文化的人「有自行煉鐵的技術」。這樣的技術,要教給下一代才能留下來。
Counting by the moon看月亮算時間
In the winter of 1602–1603 the Ming scholar Chen Di visited the southwestern coast and wrote about the Indigenous peoples he met there. He noted that they counted a month from full moon to full moon and ten months as a year. He called them by an outsider's word, 夷, and found it strange that they kept no written calendar; but a calendar kept by the moon and by memory is a way of knowing too.
1602 年冬到 1603 年初,明朝的陳第到過台灣西南海岸,寫下他遇到的原住民族。他記下他們「計月圓為一月,十月為一年」。他用明代外人的字眼「夷」稱呼他們,也覺得他們沒有寫下來的曆法很奇怪;可是看月亮、靠記憶的曆法,也是一種知識。
Knots for trade打結記帳
Chen Di also wrote that the people he met kept track of trade by tying knots in cord. He was an outsider, and his record shows what he noticed, not everything they knew.
陳第也寫到,他遇到的人「交易,結繩以識」。他是外來的人,他的紀錄只代表他看到的,不是他們知道的全部。
A language written down一種語言被寫下來
In the 1600s missionaries tried to teach the Siraya, a Pingpu people, to write their own language with the Roman alphabet. The Siraya kept using it for contracts; the last known document dates from 1818 (Lesson 10).
1600 年代,傳教士嘗試教平埔族群的西拉雅人用羅馬字母寫自己的語言。西拉雅人一直用它寫契約,留下的「新港文書」最晚的一件寫於 1818 年(第十課)。
Stories Behind the Evidence · 證據背後的故事
Four short stories about people who kept books alive.
四個小故事:讓書活下來的人。
9th century · Baghdad · 巴格達
Hunayn ibn Ishaq, a Christian of the Church of the East, became chief physician to the caliph al-Mutawakkil. He traveled to Syria, Palestine, and Egypt looking for Greek manuscripts, and ran a school of translators in Baghdad with his students.
侯奈因・伊本・伊斯哈格是東方教會的基督徒,後來成為哈里發穆塔瓦基勒的首席御醫。他到敘利亞、巴勒斯坦和埃及找希臘文的抄本,和學生在巴格達辦了一所翻譯學校。
12th century · Toledo · 托雷多
Gerard of Cremona, from northern Italy, wanted to read Ptolemy's Almagest, which did not exist in Latin. He went to Toledo, learned Arabic, finished his translation in 1175, and stayed there for the rest of his life. About 80 translations are credited to him.
義大利北部的克雷莫納的傑拉德,想讀托勒密的《天文學大成》,可是那時沒有拉丁文本。他到托雷多學阿拉伯文,1175 年譯完,然後一輩子留在那裡。大約有 80 部譯作歸在他名下。
900s → 1229 → 1998 · Byzantine world · 拜占庭世界
In the 900s a Byzantine scribe copied works of Archimedes onto parchment. In 1229 a priest at a monastery near Bethlehem scraped the pages and reused them for a prayer book. Modern scientists used ultraviolet light and X-rays to read the faint lines underneath.
900 年代,一位拜占庭的抄寫員把阿基米德的著作抄在羊皮紙上。1229 年,伯利恆附近一座修道院的教士把紙頁刮乾淨、拿去寫祈禱書。現代的科學家用紫外光和 X 光,讀出了底下淡淡的字跡。
868 CE · Dunhuang · 敦煌
A man named Wang Jie had the Diamond Sutra printed from carved wooden blocks, on behalf of his parents and for free distribution. One scroll, about five meters long, was sealed in a cave with tens of thousands of other scrolls and found again in the early 20th century.
一位叫 Wang Jie 的人,為了父母,也為了讓大家免費取得,用雕刻的木版印《金剛經》。其中一卷長約五公尺,和好幾萬件其他的卷子一起被封在洞窟裡,到二十世紀初才又被發現。
In the Curriculum · 對應課綱
These entries come from Taiwan's 12-Year Basic Education curriculum for social studies (October 2018).
下面的條目出自十二年國民基本教育課程綱要社會領域(民國 107 年 10 月)。
歷 Nb-Ⅳ-3國中・古代文化的遺產 · Junior high · the heritage of ancient cultures
伊斯蘭教的起源與發展。
The explanation asks students to discuss how the world religions shaped cultures. The translation movement in Baghdad is part of the culture of the Islamic world.課綱的說明建議「討論普世宗教所形塑的文化樣貌及世界版圖」。巴格達的翻譯運動,就是伊斯蘭世界文化的一部分。
歷 Oa-Ⅳ-1國中・近代世界的變革 · Junior high · changes in the modern world
文藝復興。
The explanation suggests discussing the origins of the Renaissance. The Latin translations from Toledo and elsewhere are part of the background.課綱的說明建議討論「文藝復興的起源及其革命性的影響」。托雷多等地的拉丁文譯本,就是它的背景之一。
Myth vs. Fact · 常見迷思
✗ Myth · 迷思Europe forgot all its learning in the “Dark Ages.”歐洲在「黑暗時代」把學問全忘了。
✓ Fact · 事實Monks kept copying books in monastery writing rooms, and Byzantine scribes kept copying Greek. Britannica notes that European universities after 1100 were stimulated by Arabic scholars.修士一直在修道院的抄寫室裡抄書,拜占庭的抄寫員也一直抄希臘文的書。Britannica 指出,1100 年以後歐洲的大學,受到阿拉伯學者的刺激。
✗ Myth · 迷思Arabic numerals were invented by Arabs.阿拉伯數字是阿拉伯人發明的。
✓ Fact · 事實They began in India in the 6th or 7th century and reached Europe through Arabic writers. That is why they are also called Hindu-Arabic numerals.它們在六或七世紀起源於印度,再透過阿拉伯文的作者傳到歐洲。所以它們也叫「印度—阿拉伯數字」。
✗ Myth · 迷思Scholars in the Islamic world only kept Greek books safe.伊斯蘭世界的學者只是把希臘的書保管好。
✓ Fact · 事實They also added new work: al-Khwārizmī's algebra in Baghdad, Ibn al-Haytham's correct model of how we see, and Avicenna's Canon of Medicine, which was a textbook in Europe until the mid-17th century.他們也做出新的研究:花拉子密在巴格達寫的代數、伊本・海什木對視覺的正確解釋,以及阿維森納的《醫典》(在歐洲一直當教科書,到十七世紀中期)。
✗ Myth · 迷思The Library of Alexandria burned in one great fire.亞歷山卓圖書館是在一場大火裡燒光的。
✓ Fact · 事實The sources disagree. Britannica itself gives a civil war in 48 BCE, another in the late 3rd century CE, and the loss of a daughter library in 391 CE. A story that appeared in the 13th century blamed the Arab general ʿAmr ibn al-ʿĀṣ, but Britannica says it is now considered a fabrication.資料彼此不一致。Britannica 自己就寫了西元前 48 年的內戰、西元三世紀後期的另一場內戰,以及 391 年一座分館的毀滅。十三世紀出現一個故事,把責任推給阿拉伯將領阿慕爾・伊本・阿斯;Britannica 說,這個說法現在被認為是捏造的。
Remember It · 記憶口訣
Before printing, a book lived only as long as people copied it.
印刷普及以前,一本書只有在有人抄的時候才活著。
Many books reached Latin Europe by way of Arabic.
很多書是經過阿拉伯文,才到說拉丁文的歐洲。
Translators and scholars also corrected and added new ideas.
譯者和學者也修正錯誤、加進新的想法。
Christians, Muslims, Jews, Buddhists, and others all helped.
基督徒、穆斯林、猶太人、佛教徒和其他人都出了力。
Classroom Activity 1 · 課堂活動一
You need · 準備材料
Steps · 步驟
Real translators like Hunayn compared several manuscripts before translating, to avoid copying mistakes. Ask students how they could do the same.
像侯奈因這樣的譯者,會先比對好幾份抄本,避免抄錯。問學生:他們可以怎麼做到一樣的事?
Classroom Activity 2 · 課堂活動二
You need · 準備材料
Steps · 步驟
Remind students that the stops on the globe show where a book changed language, as one likely path.
提醒學生:地球儀上的每一站,表示一本書換語言的地方,是一條可能的路。
Go Further · 延伸閱讀
Sources · 資料出處
Checked November 2026. What the House of Wisdom was, why the caliphs supported translation, when the Library of Alexandria was destroyed, and when the numerals reached Europe are debated; where they are, the lesson gives more than one view · 2026 年 11 月查證。智慧宮是什麼樣的地方、哈里發為什麼支持翻譯、亞歷山卓圖書館什麼時候被毀,以及數字什麼時候傳到歐洲,都有不同說法;遇到有爭論的地方,課文寫出不只一種說法